For most people the real answer is that these two are not substitutes. One tells you what is happening now; the other does bulk work at a price that barely registers. Picking one means losing whichever of those you need second.
In Chat Smith both sit in the same app, so you can send one prompt to each, compare the answers, and keep whichever holds up — without an xAI subscription, a DeepSeek API key, or any token accounting. Context carries over when you switch models mid-conversation, on Android, iOS, or in the browser, with GPT, Claude, and Gemini models there too.
Chat Smith Pro is $9.99 a month or $39.99 a year, against $30 for SuperGrok alone. One honest caveat: a multi-model app gives you the models, not every feature of each product. Grok Imagine, DeepSearch, and self-hosting stay where they are. If your work depends on those, go direct.