Anthropic's Claude is the strongest option here for the job a good tutor does: reading your draft carefully and telling you where the argument is thin. Ask where the thesis is unsupported, which paragraph drifts off topic, or what a sceptical marker would question first, and the answers tend to be specific rather than generic praise.
Strongest at: critique and explanation. It handles long drafts well, so it can comment on how the conclusion relates to the introduction, not just on individual sentences. Ask it to explain its reasoning rather than rewrite, and you get feedback you can act on in your own words.
Worth knowing: it will rewrite whole paragraphs if you ask, so be explicit that you want comments, not a replacement. Like every model here, it can also mention references that do not exist, so never cite something because a chatbot named it.
Best for: draft feedback, argument structure and understanding why a section is not working. Available in Chat Smith as Claude Sonnet 5.