Every three-way comparison ends with a recommendation, and every recommendation is wrong for part of your week. The strengths here barely overlap, so picking one means permanently giving up whichever capability you use second most.
In Chat Smith you do not have to. GPT, Gemini, and Grok models sit in the same app, so you can send one prompt to several, read the answers next to each other, and keep whichever holds up. Context carries over when you switch models mid-conversation, on Android, iOS, or in the browser — with Claude and DeepSeek models there too.
The cost difference is not subtle. ChatGPT Plus, Google AI Pro, and SuperGrok together run about $70 a month. Chat Smith Pro is $9.99 a month, or $39.99 for a year, and covers all three families.
One honest caveat: a multi-model app gives you the models, not every feature of each subscription. Deep Research, Grok Imagine, Workspace integration, and the agent surfaces stay in their native products. If your work lives inside one of those, keep that subscription. If what you want is access to strong models without picking a side, the maths is hard to argue with.